For more than three decades, the silent Smurf-colored trio known as Blue Man Group captivated theatergoers at Off Broadway’s Astor Place Theatre with its innovative Tubes. The show, first developed in the early 1990s at that bastion of experimental theater, La MaMa, was a savvy blend of clowning, sly social commentary, then-cutting-edge video display, and lots and lots of paint — splattered from drums, tubes, and even the mouths of its mute cast members onto multiple surfaces (including poncho-wearing folks seated up front).
When I last saw the Tubes in 2012, it had settled into its place as a family-friendly night out with little of the boundary-pushing edginess of its origins, though it still retained hints of its past provocation. Since Blue Man Group’s sale to Cirque du Soleil in 2017, long after Arrested Development rendered it a go-to punchline for silliness, the troupe has pursued a franchise model. There are productions in Las Vegas and Orlando as well as a touring show that has landed the outfit on Broadway for the first time.
But there’s something ho-ho-ho-hum about Blue Man Group: A New Holiday Surprise, starting with the fact that the production has not been scaled up to fit the 1,500-seat Lunt-Fontanne Theatre. Onstage screens are too small to read past the first 20 or so rows, and much of the action — including the group’s signature drumming into pools of paint that send bursts of liquid pigment skyward — occurs on a far-upstage platform that’s hard to register, let alone enjoy.
There are some nods to seasonality, including a running gag about a cackling Elf on the Shelf and a medley of holiday songs in place of the usual classic rock and pop tunes. But the chrome-domed threesome leaves much of the percussion work to an onstage drummer (Kaylie Brooke or Anastasiya Kostromina, depending on the performance) along with some pre-recorded guitar riffs. Even the multiple bits of audience participation feel pro forma and forced. This is like a Temu version of the once-mighty Blue Man Group. ★☆☆☆☆
BLUE MAN GROUP: A NEW HOLIDAY SURPRISE
Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, Broadway
Running time: 90 minutes (no intermission)
Tickets on sale through January 3 for $49 to $295

Thanks for the warning!