Count on Jamie Lloyd — the wunderkind British director of radically innovative, star-driven Broadway revivals of A Doll’s House (with Jessica Chastain), Sunset Boulevard (with Nicole Scherzinger), and last fall’s Waiting for Godot (with Keanu Reeves and Alex Winter) — to bring an inspired take to William Shakespeare’s late-16th-century comedy Much Ado About Nothing. Lloyd reimagines the play, where soldiers fresh from a big military victory enjoy a holiday at the estate of the governor of the Mediterranean seaport of Messina, as an Ibiza-style rave weekend for revelers to flirt with each other between confetti-filled disco parties.

The result is a pure blast of ebullient energy that despite the modern-day visuals retains the feeling and the bawdiness of a play whose title includes Elizabethan-era slang for vagina. This is very much a show about young men on the prowl making a big fuss over, well, pussy — though with a modicum of decorum fitting a slightly less progressive, sexually liberated time.

At the center of the action are the quick-witted frenemies Benedick and Beatrice, here played by Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell with a mesmerizing swagger and a verbal dexterity that allows centuries-old jabs and retorts to land with precision. Hiddleston carries himself with the easy confidence of a popular bro whose aversion to commitment has become a defining personality trait. (The actor’s receding hairline and habit of punctuating come-ons with a cluck of the tongue add to the impression of a man fast approaching his sell-by date as an eligible bachelor.)

much-ado-about-nothing-jamie-lloyd
The cast of Jamie Lloyd’s ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ (Photo: Andy Henderson)

Atwell matches Hiddleston’s frisky, abrasive energy, while revealing a softer side that her cousin Hero (Mara Huf) and servant Margaret (Mason Alexander Park) are all too eager to exploit. Together with Benedick’s buddies Don Pedro (Gerald Kyd) and Claudio (James Phoon), who’s engaged to Hero, they scheme to convince Benedick and Beatrice that the other is secretly in love with them but too proud/stubborn to admit it. The plot works in part because Atwell and Hiddleston play so well off each other that their romance really does seem inevitable.

Lloyd has a great deal of fun with his leads’ reputations, even trotting out cardboard standees of the actors dressed as their characters from the Marvel Cinematic Universe at one point. (The horn on Hiddleston’s Loki helmet proves a useful prop for some NSFW miming by Margaret as she sings Benedick’s praises to a reluctant Beatrice.)

Speaking of singing, Park pulls out a microphone multiple times to deliver strong, throaty renditions of pop tunes ranging from Taylor Dayne’s “Tell It to My Heart” to All-4-One’s “I Swear” that both enhance and deepen the comedic and romantic narrative. Lloyd also draws from his personal Gen X party playlist to cue up bygone hits from Missy Elliott, C+C Music Factory, and the Beastie Boys to create a loose onstage envtarironment, the kind where attractive young people might be more open to the possibility of love.

much-ado-about-nothing-broadway-2026
Forbes Masson, Mara Huf, Philip Olagoke, James Phoon, and Tim Steed in ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ (Photo: Andy Henderson)

The party atmosphere is heightened by Soutra Gilmour’s set and costume design, and the disco-style lighting of Jon Clark. As with most Lloyd productions, there’s a minimum of traditional set pieces — aside from a giant inflated pink heart that descends onto the stage during Act 1 and serves as a critical bit of camouflage for Benedick as he tries to listen in on conversations about Beatrice’s supposed attraction to him. He also seeks to hide in the mounds of hot-pink confetti strewn all around the ground, like a little boy convinced that covering his face means that he cannot be seen.

The spareness of the design, aside from the occasional table or chair, emboldens the cast to throw themselves more physically into their roles — and it’s a treat to see Hiddleston boogie with abandon or literally roll across the stage in a demented, self-defeating attempt to escape without calling attention to himself.

jamie-lloyd-much-ado-about-nothing
Mason Alexander Park (center) and the cast of ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ (Photo: Andy Henderson)

Lloyd also finds clever ways to handle some of the convoluted plotting in the second act, when virginal Hero is falsely accused of betraying her fiancé in a ploy cooked up by Don John (Tim Steed), the estranged illegitimate brother of Don Pedro, Prince of Aragon. The director leans into the absurdity of the ruse with a call-back to the Act 1 masquerade ball he stages with the entire 10-person cast wearing furry costumes complete with oversize animal heads (and a lone robot head). When Margaret is spotted wearing Hero’s Tweety Bird head while hooking up with the schlubby Borachio (Mika Onyx Johnson), the result is an understandable confusion over mistaken identity.

But it’s impossible to take the scheming seriously, which is just as well. Just when we find ourselves questioning something that seems dated about this centuries-old play, we find our resistance to its charms falling like the waves of confetti fluttering to the stage. The confident performances by Hiddleston and Atwell help with that; the stars convey a genuine sense of delight in each other’s company (particularly in an athletic turn before the curtain call).

But in the end, this Much Ado About Nothing succeeds because of Lloyd’s approach. The man has an eye (and an ear) for a good party. And here he transforms the Bard’s work into a virtual musical comedy that is contemporary, light on its feet, and irresistibly fun. ★★★★☆

MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING
Winter Garden Theatre, Broadway
Running time: 2 hours, 20 minutes (with one intermission)
Tickets on sale through January 10 for $59 to $799

Share This Post