What do we do with the monsters in our midst? Bruce Norris’ unforgettable drama Downstate challenges us to consider that question and to recognize the humanity in people who instinctually repulse us: men convicted of sexual offenses against minors. The play, which premiered at Chicago’s Steppenwolf in 2018 and got an acclaimed Off Broadway run in 2022, arrives on Broadway with a new director, Joe Mantello, but two of its original stars, Francis Guinan and K. Todd Freeman. And the effect is both discomfiting and devastating. Not to mention laugh-out-loud funny, in a pitch-dark way that helps reduce the tension that inflates like a balloon set to blow at any moment.
In the opening scene, we meet a well-heeled banker named Andy (Thomas Sadoski, a convincingly fidgety bundle of nerves) who’s come to a dingy southern Illinois group house with his hyper-assertive wife (Cassie Beck) to confront the man they have both identified as the source of all his longstanding depression and anxiety: the former piano teacher who sexually assaulted Andy when he was 12. But Guinan’s Fred defies our expectations, looking less like a pervy predator than a kindly, portly old man slumped in a wheelchair. He nods as Andy reads from a prepared statement calling him a “fundamentally evil person” and fills one of several awkward silences with the question: “Are you sure you don’t want some coffee?”
The meeting/confrontation is repeatedly interrupted by the other residents of the facility (designed by Scott Pask and lit by Heather Gilbert to call attention to its seediness). There’s Dee (Freeman), a tart-tongued former actor who seduced a 14-year-old boy during a touring production of Peter Pan and who has a tendency to provoke everyone he encounters, with the possible exception of Fred. (He even tries to justify his crime by citing obscure tribes that he claims initiated boys even younger into sexual rituals.) There’s Gio (Al’Jaleel McGhee, slightly overplaying the brashness), a buff chatterbox who considers himself different from, and morally superior to, his housemates since he’s straight and regards his conviction for statutory rape of an adolescent girl as “a different ball of wax.” And then there’s Felix (Adrian Martinez, wonderfully recessive), a loner who makes an ill-advised trip to the local public library’s computers to reach out to the now-teenage daughter he molested as a little girl.

There’s no question of the men’s guilt — they each did ghastly things to minors — though nearly all of them are quick to cite some mitigating circumstance that allows them to carry on. Norris expertly seeds information about his characters as well as their present circumstances in gradual doses. A new city law expanding the perimeter around area schools means the residents’ closest bus stop and favorite grocery story are now off-limits to them. We also learn why the front window is boarded up and a baseball sits by the door, why there’s a tube TV in the corner of the living room with no sign of a cable box or WiFi hookup. (The internet is off limits to these men, as are cellphones, alcohol, and overnight visitors.) And how Fred ended up in his wheelchair.
In Norris’ telling, nobody is off the hook. Not the four ex-cons shacking up together. And not the upstanding citizens who understandably want to remove sex offenders from their sight even after they’ve served their time. Gio’s alarmingly young Staples co-worker (Ivy Wolk) lives in her own bubble of medically prescribed CBD vape smoke, while Andy’s Gucci purse-clutching wife often seems more performative than supportive of her husband’s mental health — or just plain pushy. Only Liza Colón-Zayas (The Bear), as the gruff, overworked probation officer, comes off as a level-headed voice of reason without a hidden agenda. Mantello takes a broader approach to some of the characterizations than Pam MacKinnon did in the Off Broadway production, perhaps in recognition that Broadway audiences may need to work a little harder to build anything resembling empathy for felons. But this revival maintains a delicate balance that enables the revelations of the second act to land with shattering force.
Freeman, last seen as Willy Loman’s kind-hearted neighbor Charley in Death of a Salesman, sashays about the set like an outré mother hen while also mixing it up with anyone who dares challenge his off-kilter worldview. He even scores some points with Andy discussing the appropriate punishment for sex offenders like him, and whether they deserve harsher treatment than murderers. Freeman also has an easy rapport with Guinan, who is the emotional center of the show. The veteran character actor is riveting as Fred, a man whose outwardly benign and genial nature can be seen as an avatar for the banality of evil or perhaps how time can mellow a monster. But when Andy returns to the house in the second act, this time without his wife, Guinan reveals how Fred’s solicitousness can also be read as something more sinister. Even now, he seems capable of grooming. Not all predators are the same, or how we might imagine them. It’s a fascinatingly nuanced portrait of a complicated, morally compromised man.
Norris, who earned a Pulitzer Prize for his 2011 re-examination of A Raisin in the Sun in Clybourne Park, produced another masterpiece in this provocative look at individuals whom society rightly rejects. Do people whose actions disgust us still deserve our consideration? Downstate does what only great theater can do: shed light on even the darkest, most abject corners of human existence. This is a play that is not to be missed. ★★★★★
DOWNSTATE
Booth Theatre, Broadway
Running time: 2 hours, 30 minutes (with one intermission)
Tickets on sale through January 10 for $51 to $399
