The Fantasticks, the allegorical love story that ran for four decades in the tiny Sullivan Street Playhouse in Greenwich Village without once contemplating a transfer to the brighter lights and bigger houses of Broadway. And for good reason. This self-consciously modest musical, with a score by Harvey Schmidt and book and lyrics by Tom Jones, was deliberately even more stripped-down than Thornton Wilder’s Our Town. Eight actors, two musicians, the faintest hint of a set, and basic props plucked out of an onstage trunk by a silent character named The Mute who physically embodied a wall between the show’s two families.

Now this wisp of a show has opened at Broadway’s smallest venue, the 600-seat Hayes Theater, in a thoroughly charming revival that soups up the production values a smidge while maintaining the DIY spirit of the original. Director-choreographer Christopher Gattelli opens the show with a nod to the Off Broadway run, with an onstage harpist and pianist and a trunk reading “Sullivan Street Playhouse,” before pulling back to reveal a slightly more elaborate, stylized set by Jason Sherwood, props by Kathy Fabian, and throwback costumes by Linda Cho.

The story, loosely based on a 19th-century play by Cyrano de Bergerac author Edmond Rostand, has also gotten a 21st-century update (completed by Jones before his death in 2023 at age 95). The central couple of Luisa and Matt, next-door neighbors who fall in love with each other after being forbidden to do so by their wily single dads, are now two twinky lads named Lewis (Nathan Levy) and Matt (Maxim Chlumecky) who’ve been unwittingly nudged together by their frenemy single moms, Mildred Hucklebee (Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer) and Bessie Mae Bellomy (Ruthie Ann Miles), in a way that anticipates the modern deployment of reverse psychology and helicopter parenting. (The script also excises the word “rape,” deployed frequently in the original script during an abduction scene that the parents arrange to have staged so that Matt can heroically rescue his love and justify the end of the neighbors’ enmity.)

fantasticks-Nathan Levy and Maxim Chlumecky
Nathan Levy and Maxim Chlumecky in ‘The Fantasticks’ (Photo: Joan Marcus)

Despite the odds, it works. Levy’s Lewis, with his fixation on royalty and love for his grandmother’s glue-paste necklace, could be any number of princessy gay boys, while Chlumecky captures the callowness of an eager student who repeatedly betrays his inexperience despite projecting otherwise. (Speaking of the wall separating him from Lewis, he notes that their parents “built it ages ago — last month.”) Together, they project an adorable teen-drama chemistry, blending sweetly on duets like “Metaphor” and “Soon It’s Going to Rain.”

Kritzer and Miles are not only wonderful singers but gifted comedic actresses, bringing unique twists to throwaway lines and earning laughs from physical gags (as when Kritzer’s Navy veteran rolls up her sleeve to reveal her bicep tattoos). Each actress brings an added bit of oomph and individuality to flesh out characters who by their very nature are archetypes. Shout-out to Sam Davis, whose new orchestrations not only change the keys of many songs and cut back on Luisa/Lewis’ coloratura but also expand the instrumentation from piano and harp to a seven-member band. The result is a lush, romantic sound that never overpowers the story’s simplicity.

Zane Phillips injects a predatory wolfishness to the narrator, El Gallo, the architect of the abduction who later serves as an older-gentleman shoulder for Lewis to cry on when Matt embarks on solo adventures in the second act. You half expect Phillips, a gym-buff hunk who nearly bursts out of his tight black ensemble, to interrupt his quasi-seduction with a telltale Grindr notification on his phone — though he keeps everything strictly PG-13. The actor also delivers his solos, particularly the staple “Try to Remember,” with rich tonality.

fantasticks-2026-el-gallo
Zane Phillips in ‘The Fantasticks’ (Photo: Joan Marcus)

David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila also delight as the aged actors hired to stage Lewis’ abduction, milking ancient vaudevillian shtick with practiced aplomb. (The abduction scene itself, with its fitfully staged wooden-sword fight, is a comparative disappointment.) Finally, Ahmad Simmons keeps the scenes moving as the twinkle-toed Mute, beaming his Pepsodent smile and injecting some light tap-dancing.

No revival can shake loose all of the cobwebs from this show, especially in a second act that takes a darker turn and that does not feel necessary. (Comparisons to Stephen Sondheim and James Lapine’s Into the Woods are inevitable.) Jones cooks up a weak excuse to separate the young lovers and postpone the inevitable happily-ever-after. Matt, who’s already been away to college and endured a staged assault on his beloved, decides he needs to experience more of the real world before he can settle down. The act also has some of the show’s weaker songs, with lyrics that can lapse into stilted, grammatically challenged incomprehensibility, as in the Act 2 opener: “What at night seems oh so scenic may be cynic in the light.”

Still, you’d have to be a hard-hearted cynic yourself to resist the charms of The Fantasticks. This artfully staged revival conjures a nostalgia for plain storytelling, elegant folk melodies with a hint of classicism, and unembellished romanticism — all in a still somewhat intimate setting. No flying witches or swooping vampires or American patriots on spinning turntables. Sometimes all you need is a bell and a whistle — or, in this case, a piano and a harp — to create musical magic. ★★★★☆

THE FANTASTICKS
Hayes Theater, Broadway
Running time: 2 hours, 15 minutes (with one intermission)
Tickets on sale through February 7 for $79 to $275

Share This Post